Religion is way more dangerous that science. Science is a tool, like a hammer. It serves a function, but can be used by people outside that prescribed function.
Religion is an idea, a way of life. Especially in Abrahamic religions, it teaches people of a group they're better than other people of a different group.
Science, by definition, involves rational thought. Removing the rational thought process from something created or developed by science invites danger.
Religion, by definition, teaches people to eschew rational thought and take things on faith while usually ignoring actual, indisputable, real-world evidence. Add irrational passion into THAT mix and that's when trouble happens.
So shortsighted. Man invented gunpowder and man decided to use it to kill either out of greed, envy, jealousy, hatred in his heart. Besides, science is just nature explained. Who discovered and explained it, man. What is in the heart of man is what will come out, every time, for good or for ill. Blame is another thing in people's heart. Most people don't want to except responsibility for what is in their hearts and subsequently in their actions. Just say'n.
Jason ON Your first statement is true indeed. We observed and explained and harnessed nature. Your 2nd statement shows you don't know your own heart, and how little you understand human history, no offense. Religion put greed and envy, and jealousy, and racism, and self-centeredness in man's heart? That is the first time I have heard that. Again, no offense, just being blunt.
Is being an Atheist a religion?? If not, how do you explain it when they go postal?? Maybe we need to clarify what "religion" is.... Scientology is considered a religion, no?? and it's based on science. Being consumed with greed could be considered a religion, right? If all forms of worship are "religion", then you would be right, but when people hear the word "religion" they normally assume it to mean Catholics, Protestants, Baptist, Mormon, Jewish, Muslim... etc. and that is the normal intent when saying "religion or religious" is to place blame on them. True "religion" based on what you worship needs to have a different name so painting with a broad brush isn't the intent... or is it?
Tim McAdam most people who go postal are not atheists. People who go postal are, in fact, in an irrational state of mind. Driven by anger, frustration or fear and regardless of their religion are exceptions to the norm.
Blair Warner, religions didn't put those things in man's heart, I agree, but religions did reinforce and indoctrinate those ideals into cultures, taking what one or two people in a tribe might have thought and making them the norm over the course of generations.
Tim McAdam, you're right, we should be more specific on the usage of the term religion.
per "define religion" in Google:
re·li·gion/riˈlijən/ Noun: 1. The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God or gods. 2. Details of belief as taught or discussed.
For the sake of this discussion I think we can all agree to these definitions.
But I believe you're right, anything that brings peace to the (proverbial) soul can be defined as a religion. For some it would be playing golf, for others it might be wilderness hiking and others still it might be automechanics.
Sounds like science is your religion, then, for you worship it, but... how can you worship a body of information and facts? I guess it is more accurate to say you worship nature, and now you are back to prehistoric beliefs, like sun worship and stuff. Religion must have an object of worship or it cannot be called "religion". Call it anything else, but not religion. Sorry, I typed this before you put forth the Google definition..
Jason ON Every tribe, culture, generation, people, exhibit greed, envy, jealousy, self-centeredness, resulting in racism, hate, murder, etc. Religion just put it in scalable, definable, terms placing it in contrast to their opposites and, placing value on such, and de-value (for lack of better words) on ther former.
Jeff Chapman What causes the anger, and fear and frustration and irrational state of mind? Lack of purpose and value. Lack of being loved and loving back, etc. which, all true religions espouse as true values, no?
I have to go, but my point is, without intentionally debating was that MAN, PEOPLE, HUMAN BEINGS are the cause of all societal trouble regardless of science, or religion, or education, or the lack thereof. Take a human with a clean slate, and he/she will invent and do all the things we have done the last 10,000 years all over again. Agree, or disagree?
Jason ON ..... I'm just being a smart arse here....... "Religion is an idea, a way of life. Especially in Abrahamic religions, it teaches people of a group they're better than other people of a different group." Would that make Sheldon a religion? LOL!
Tim McAdam Scientology is based on science in the same way that religion is: it isn't.
Wiki states that religion is a way to tie humanity to spirituality. That sounds like a good start, and precludes greed from being a religion. Greed could be a tenant of a religion, but greed itself is not.
Logan Cate greed toward something is a form of idol worship... you may not be "praying" to it , but it is what you might be "worshiping" and sometimes basing your life worth on or putting your "faith" in....
Logan Cate again I call for the creation of a sarcasm font. Blair Warner religions may espouse those values but actions speak louder than words and their actions are usually the opposite of their words.
Jason ON No, they are philosophies, ways of thinking and life, and they worship themselves, mankind, not a supreme being. Of course, if you want to get technical they are humanistic based "religions" since they worship human beings as the ultlmate "god-like" being.
Jason ON I can't agree with your disagreement above. Regardless of whether one is a athiest or theist, your disagreement does not hold water that man is basically altruistic. If there is no god, then "altruistic" man invented religion and god, and if there is a god, "altruistic" man distorted it all. However you look at it the proof is in the pudding, look at us now. Look at history. The clean slate I mentioned above is what mankind had years a go and this is what we ended up with, and we STILL have no answer or see any change in sight. The only true answer is for us to admit we are all basically self-centered which results in greed and everything thereafter, and figure out the answer from there as the starting place of our journey or search, however you want to call it.
Did you know dog meat is served in restaurants in South Korea? I didn't. In the United States and most western countries, Fido is a family companion and while it's not ethical to judge another culture by our standards, anyone who doesn't at least (humanely) butcher the animal first is acting without proper care. South Korea relies on western consumerism for their economy and needs to be aware that we do not accept the practice of skinning and boiling dogs alive. Originally shared by April Benney Over 6,000 restaurants in South Korea are still serving dog meat even though it is now illegal. In many Asian countries dogs are boiled alive or skinned alive when slaughtered. It's an unbelievably horrendous & torturous way to die. I know a lot of you hate seeing this kind of posts on G+, but the Asian industry slaughtering dogs & cats is how I first got involved in animal rights & it will always be my main animal welfare concern. It's intolerable what is happen...
I don't make a lot of personal posts so please bear with me. #Rufus hasn't been doing well for the past week or so. I mean, he's 13 (at least), and has slowed down due to age, but the past week or two he's been acting like every movement is a Herculean effort. A few times in the past couple of weeks his rear legs have given out on him completely to where I've had to pick him up and carry him which is, in itself, telling. Rufus has always hated being carried and struggled continuously when I did so. Yesterday while petting him I noticed two golf-ball sized things up under his chin. Now, they may be benign lipomas as Rufus is covered with them (one one each thigh, one on each shoulder, one on his chest and a few smaller bumps here and there) or they may be indicative of something else. I'm no vet and aside from emergency medic battlefield training I have no medical experience whatsoever, but these new things seem to be where your or mine lymph nodes are located....
I'm shutting down Google+ for the night and quite possibly for the weekend. Why? This stupid #gifwars thing people are so proud of. This Adam Black guy said he doesn't like gifs and now everyone is mass trolling him. Having been mass trolled like this I can relate to him easily enough. Have an opinion and the collective might of Google+'s lower class denizens jump on a bandwagon. I just saw a post where someone wanted to jump on board and had to get clarification she was tagging the proper Adam Black. She wasn't even connected to him ! Nor was she a part of the original discussion. She just wanted to follow the herd. When I called her out of it she claimed, "one gif doesn't make a troll." Perhaps not, but she's contributing to a larger troll effort. One straw doesn't break the camel's back, but thousands will. So, tonight, Google+ disgusts me. It probably will tomorrow as well. And possibly Sunday. I gave up Google+ for two months this spring...
Comments
You created gunpowder and guns and allowed me to shoot a girl in the head for wanting to learn all those devil teachings you figured out.
Yours,
Religion
Religion is an idea, a way of life. Especially in Abrahamic religions, it teaches people of a group they're better than other people of a different group.
Religion, by definition, teaches people to eschew rational thought and take things on faith while usually ignoring actual, indisputable, real-world evidence. Add irrational passion into THAT mix and that's when trouble happens.
What is in the "heart" of man? Easy, what did religion put there?
Tim McAdam, you're right, we should be more specific on the usage of the term religion.
per "define religion" in Google:
re·li·gion/riˈlijən/
Noun:
1. The belief in and worship of a superhuman controlling power, esp. a personal God or gods.
2. Details of belief as taught or discussed.
For the sake of this discussion I think we can all agree to these definitions.
But I believe you're right, anything that brings peace to the (proverbial) soul can be defined as a religion. For some it would be playing golf, for others it might be wilderness hiking and others still it might be automechanics.
:o)
"Religion is an idea, a way of life. Especially in Abrahamic religions, it teaches people of a group they're better than other people of a different group."
Would that make Sheldon a religion? LOL!
Wiki states that religion is a way to tie humanity to spirituality. That sounds like a good start, and precludes greed from being a religion. Greed could be a tenant of a religion, but greed itself is not.
greed toward something is a form of idol worship... you may not be "praying" to it , but it is what you might be "worshiping" and sometimes basing your life worth on or putting your "faith" in....
Blair Warner religions may espouse those values but actions speak louder than words and their actions are usually the opposite of their words.